Members of the Kansas 4-H All Star meat judging team include (left to right) coach Steph Witberler, Luke Frankhauser, Gwenyth Fry, Callan Smith, Calley Stubbs, Lyle Perrier and coach Katie Lybarger. | Download this photo
Kansas 4-H meat judging team wins national contest
American Royal win is the first-ever for a Kansas team
Oct. 27, 2022
By Maddy Rohr, K-State Research and Extension news service
MANHATTAN, Kan. — The Kansas 4-H All Star meat judging team was crowned national champions, beating teams from 14 states during the 4-H Meat Judging Contest championship held at the American Royal in Kansas City.
It is the first-ever national title for a Kansas team, which won by 27 points over Texas. The contest has been in existence since 1970.
“The Kansas team was successful due to their work ethic,” said Katie Lybarger, a meat science graduate student at Kansas State University and the team’s coach.
“These kids met with us for virtual practices weekly, studied on their own time, and practiced from sunup to sundown in the days leading up to the contest. They never once complained and took advantage of every opportunity to get better. More importantly, they had fun together throughout all of this and had a very strong team bond.”
The team placed first in retail cut judging, retail cut identification, oral reasons and overall judging. They were second in pork judging and beef judging.
The Kansas 4-H All-Star Meat Judging Team consisted of individuals who placed in the top 10 at the state 4-H meat judging contest in August. According to Lybarger, students needed to have excellent meat evaluation and decision-making skills, and exceptional oral communication.
The team included:
- Luke Fankhauser, Greenwood County.
- Gwenyth Fry, Southwind District (Bourbon County).
- Callan Smith, Barber County.
- Calley Stubbs, Sunflower District (Wallace County).
- Lyle Perrier, Greenwood County.
- Lillian Hulse, Central Kansas District (Ottawa County).
- Liam Nichols, Central Kansas District (Ottawa County).
In addition to Lybarger, the team was coached by Steph Witberler.
“Steph and I enjoyed coaching this team because it was an opportunity to invest back into the next generation of meat judging,” Lybarger said. “We both competed on the K-State meat judging team and found the experience to be incredibly impactful.”
Lybarger credited the 4-H members’ coaches and volunteers at the local level who, she says, “have invested years into these kids.
“They truly give these students the essential meat judging foundation needed to be successful at this level. Our roles as the coaches of the all star team was just to take the kids to that next step.”
Individually, four Kansas 4-H members placed in the top 10, including Stubbs (first), Perrier (third), Fankhauser (fifth) and Fry (seventh).
Stubbs placed first in retail cut identification with the only perfect score in the contest; first in oral reasons, and first total judging. She was second in pork judging and retail cut judging.
Perrier was second in retail cut identification, third in retail cut judging and oral reasons, and fourth in total judging. Fankhasuer was fourth in beef judging. Fry was third in total judging and fifth in retail cut judging.
Students evaluated six classes of carcasses or cuts and gave three sets of oral reasons during the contest. Additionally, they identified 30 retail cuts and specified the species, primal, and cookery of each. This year, the team evaluated pork carcasses, beef ribs, pork loins, beef rounds, porterhouse steaks, and pork blade chops. Reasons were given on the pork carcasses, pork loins and porterhouse steaks.
Lybarger said: “This was a talented and hard-working group of leaders, and we feel very lucky to have gotten to know them each through this team.”